On this page
- What are the main differences between Etsy and Amazon?
- Which products suit which marketplace?
- How do they differ in logistics?
- Can you sell on both marketplaces?
- What should you base your decision on when starting out?
- How do you factor in shipping costs when choosing a marketplace?
- Frequently asked questions
Short answer
Etsy suits handmade, vintage, designer and personalised products, while Amazon suits branded, standard and fast-selling products. Getting started is easier on Etsy, and orders are usually shipped one by one from Türkiye. Amazon involves more competition and documentation; as volume grows, the overseas warehouse model comes to the fore.
What are the main differences between Etsy and Amazon?
| Topic | Etsy | Amazon |
|---|---|---|
| Product type | Handmade, vintage, craft supplies, design | Every category; branded and standard products |
| Buyer expectations | Originality and a story | Speed, price and trust |
| Getting started | Quick shop setup | More documents and verification |
| Fee structure | Listing, transaction and payment processing fees | Selling plan fee, referral fees, and FBA fees if the warehouse is used |
| Competition | Moderate, depending on the niche | Usually high |
| Logistics | Mostly shipped one by one from Türkiye | Seller-fulfilled (FBM) or Amazon's warehouse (FBA) |
On Etsy, vintage items must be at least 20 years old. Fees can change; check the current rates on the marketplaces.
Which products suit which marketplace?
| Product | Better marketplace |
|---|---|
| Handmade jewellery, ceramics and textiles | Etsy |
| Personalised gifts | Etsy |
| Digital products (patterns, templates) | Etsy |
| Branded home and kitchen products | Amazon |
| Consumables that are bought repeatedly | Amazon |
| Spare parts and accessories | Amazon and eBay |
How do they differ in logistics?
On Etsy, orders are mostly shipped one by one from Türkiye as micro exports; the processing time and shipping cost are shown on the listing (Etsy shipping profile). The same model can be used on Amazon with seller fulfillment; however, fast delivery badges and short delivery times require products to be shipped in bulk to Amazon's warehouse in the destination country (what you need to sell on Amazon).
Can you sell on both marketplaces?
Yes. Many brands sell their original and personalised products on Etsy and their standard products on Amazon. Integration tools can be used to manage stock and orders in one place; we cover the shipping-side options on our API and marketplace integration page.
What should you base your decision on when starting out?
- Is your product handmade or original?
- What are your target price range and profit margin?
- What are your production capacity and stock model?
- How ready are your documents and brand?
- How much time can you spend on customer service?
How do you factor in shipping costs when choosing a marketplace?
On both marketplaces, the shipping cost is part of the product price. Calculate the product's chargeable weight and work out the shipping cost for your target countries; then build it into the price as free shipping or charge it separately. With the Amazon warehouse model, you also need to account for the cost of bulk shipments, warehouse fees and taxes in the destination country. To calculate with your own dimensions, use our volumetric weight calculator.
Frequently asked questions
Is it easier to sell on Etsy or Amazon?
Etsy is usually easier for setting up a shop and making the first sales; Amazon involves more documents, competition and operational work.
Can you sell factory-made products on Etsy?
Etsy focuses on handmade, vintage and craft supplies. If you use a production partner, you must disclose it; reselling ready-made products as handmade is against the rules.
Can you sell on Amazon and ship from Türkiye?
Yes. With seller fulfillment, orders can be shipped from Türkiye; for products where buyers expect fast delivery, the Amazon warehouse model has the advantage.
Which marketplace has lower fees?
The fee structures differ and can change; compare the current fees on both marketplaces against your product price to work out the total cost.
Is eBay an option too?
Yes. eBay is a strong alternative, especially for spare parts, collectibles and second-hand items.
Is it a problem to sell the same product on both Etsy and Amazon?
No; but products on Etsy must comply with its handmade and originality rules, and stock must be kept in sync across the two channels.